Grant Morrison, the visionary behind All-Star Superman and Action Comics, has finally weighed in on James Gunn’s Superman movie—and his take might just surprise you. In a world where every Superman film sparks heated debates, Morrison’s verdict is a game-changer. During a candid Reddit AMA, Morrison didn’t hold back, declaring, ‘I thought it was the best Superman movie yet!’ But here’s where it gets controversial: with die-hard fans still swearing by classics like Superman: The Movie and Man of Steel, Morrison’s bold claim is sure to ignite some fiery discussions. And this is the part most people miss: Morrison’s praise isn’t just about nostalgia—it’s about how Gunn’s film stays true to the comics while revitalizing the DC brand for a new era.
Released in July 2025, Superman soared past expectations, grossing over $615 million worldwide and becoming the year’s highest-grossing superhero film. Gunn, who also co-leads DC Studios, openly drew inspiration from Morrison and Frank Quitely’s All-Star Superman, a fact that adds an intriguing layer to Morrison’s glowing review. But let’s not forget—Morrison didn’t stop at Superman. In the same AMA, he praised DC’s Absolute Universe, calling it ‘the best update on these characters since the Silver Age.’ Bold words, right? Yet, he admits he’s not entirely up-to-speed on Damian Wayne’s evolution as Robin, a character he created in 2006. ‘I don’t get comp boxes anymore!’ he quipped, adding that Damian ‘should probably become a whole new costumed character.’ Talk about a controversial suggestion!
Morrison also dropped a fascinating tidbit about his missed opportunity with Spider-Man. Years ago, he envisioned a story where the classic, nerdy Ditko Spider-Man meets his modern, married-to-MJ counterpart, with Mysterio as the villain. But here’s the twist: Morrison couldn’t muster the enthusiasm to write it. ‘I just bounce off him,’ he admitted. ‘I don’t have any ideas for Spider-Man at all for some reason!’ Is this a character only certain writers can truly capture, or is Morrison onto something bigger?
Now, let’s dive into the movie itself. In Superman, the Man of Tomorrow faces crises both at home and abroad, his every move scrutinized. This gives tech mogul Lex Luthor the perfect opening to eliminate the Man of Steel once and for all. Can Lois Lane and Superman’s loyal dog, Krypto, save him before time runs out? Starring David Corenswet as Superman/Clark Kent, Rachel Brosnahan as Lois Lane, and Nicholas Hoult as Lex Luthor, the film boasts a stellar cast, including Edi Gathegi, Anthony Carrigan, and Nathan Fillion. With Superman now available on HBO Max, Digital, 4K Ultra HD, Blu-ray, and DVD, the question remains: does it truly deserve Morrison’s title of ‘best Superman movie yet’?
Here’s where you come in: Do you agree with Morrison’s assessment, or does another Superman film hold the top spot in your heart? And what about Damian Wayne—should he ditch the Robin mantle for a new identity? Let’s spark a debate in the comments—because when it comes to superheroes, there’s no such thing as a wrong opinion, just passionate ones!
